Showing posts with label tax credit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tax credit. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Hollywood vs. Bollywood: An Even Playing Field?




When one mentions Bollywood, to most people, the first and sometimes only thought that comes to mind is the sensational film, Slumdog Millionaire. However, India has realized and capitalized on a wildly successful industry that exports more films than the U.S. In fact, India exports on average 1000 films a year to a worldwide audience of over 3 billion, compared to the United States’ 500 films and 2.6 billion people respectively. Our world can be considered both a “global village” and a globalized economy, which refers to “the growing dominance of western forms of political, economic, and cultural life.” Although this has helped Bollywood thrive, it has also shaped the industry and created competition.

But has globalization also made for an uneven playing field?



Globalization has allowed the United States to take full advantage of the advancements in both technology and capitalism, evident by the $60 million average that the film industry spends to produce a movie. Comparatively, Bollywood only spends around $5 million per film. Furthermore, 50% of the movies produced by Bollywood are never released, and of those that are, 95% result in losses. Moreover, America’s dominance and wealth has afforded them the ability to offer filmmakers tax credits and subsidies. Michael Cieply of The New York Times examined this aspect of the film industry and notes that states will offer film producers astounding tax credits to shoot the movie in that state. The Texas Film Commission states that movie companies can receive 5%-22.5% in tax credits in Texas, based on how much they spend. Additionally, ticket prices in India go for $1 on average, compared to $8.38 in the U.S. The Indian film industry will have a very difficult time competing with these incentives. They are not afforded tax credits, and due to the high-risk environment, cannot spend $100 million on a movie like U.S. productions can.


Yet, Michael Schuman of Time notes that the world is now turning the tables, with many countries such as China and India exporting their goods. He states that although, in the past, globalization was a one-way street, “it is knitting together a society that, more than ever, is truly global.” Whereas developed nations were solely exporting to developing ones, countries such as the U.S. are now consuming those nations’ goods.

So, has globalization been advantageous or detrimental to Bollywood?


Although globalization has given countries such as India a worldwide market to consume their movies, it has also afforded the United States the ability to hand out subsidies to film producers, once again destabilizing the playing field.

Sources